Next to the arrival of immigrant persons, nothing so exercises the anger of our old friend Dave Watford and his mates at the Dog and Duck as the imposition of taxes. All taxes. Any taxes. Death duties, sales taxes, income taxes……the mere mention of the “t ” word is enough to unleash paroxysms of indignant wrath. As we have heard it so many times we think we can give a fair summary of their case, which goes like this
I’ll tell you what’s wrong with this country, mate —taxes. I work hard, and they just take it. For what? So some bloke in a suit can sit in an office pushing paper? I don’t see any of it. Roads are still full of ‘oles, the(expletive deleted) NHS is on life suppawt, and don’t get me started on foreign aid. They say it pays for schools an ‘ospitals—well I haven’t been in school for 40 years and I haven’t seen a(expletive deleted) doctor since ’98. Why should I pay for stuff I don’t use? And all these entrepreneurs, they’re the ones wots creating jobs. Government just gets in the way. If they cut taxes, we’d all be better off. More money in our pockets, less wasted on(expletive deleted) bureaucracy.
Dave, despite the obvious logical fallacies in your arguments. we respect you! We know you and your kind work hard and on the whole put in more than you take out. We know how your lives are centred on family and community, and that the world can seem a harsh, bewildering place. But can we, dare we, just take a short time to offer the counter-intuitive case? Just because every argument by its nature always carries a counter point.
For we believe that taxes and their imposition do more than pay for armies, police and courts (which they do). We believe they do more than generate economic growth (and we will show that they do indeed) That they create more stable societies-and we have strong evidence for that. But what we really believe is that the idea of taxes lies at the very beginnings of Civilisation, and are what made it possible to rise above the level of stone age farmers and grangers. It’s that profound. In the next few weeks we shall be running a series of blogs which explore these themes. If only for the sake of balance. In the meantime compare Finland (top tax rate 57.65%, rigidly enforced) with Chad (top tax rate 30%, barely enforced), and answer these questions:
1 Which has GDP per capita of a $53 189 and b which $1420?
2 which of the two boasts a universal healthcare, free education, strong infrastructure, low corruption. and which b Fragile institutions, limited public services, poor infrastructure, high corruption.?
3 Which of the two do you think has Higher life expectancy, lower infant mortality, combined with top global rankings in happiness and education?
ANSWERS TO QUIZ
1 a Finland b Chad
2 a Finland b Chad
3 Finland
#economics #tax #infrastructure #growth #GDP wealth creation
Learning, Science and Society 