It’s time to wrap up our counter-intuitive series Why Taxes are good for you. We started it as a slightly cheeky riposte to the massively funded and relentlessly intolerant opposition who insist that taxes must be, always and everywhere, a despicable evil. In the first part we met the industrious but not very knowledgeable Dave Watford who expounded upon the best of their arguments from his post at the bar of the Dog and Duck. We went on to learn the rather chilling truths about life in a low tax nirvana, where their are no laws, roads nor health services and violent death lies around every corner. Part three considered the little known but incredibly well documented story of 18th Century China whose low taxes led it to be conquered by the tax- funded armies of ruthlessly hypocritical western nations. Whatever else they are for, taxes are good for your health as we showed in part 4. We felt that part 5, despite being a historical argument, was crucial. No taxes equals no economy. And if you really do want to get rich, the best chance of doing it is by starting from a well-taxed society, as our part six concluded. We provided lots of links and books and that sort of thing for you to read in order to draw your own conclusions. And so we said ” Quod erat demonstrandum“

Except it wasn’t. Isn’t. And probably never will be. Because we forgot one thing. The benefits of taxes are long term, and require an immediate short term loss. Think how Dave Watford sees it. Money taken from his pocket to pay for armies, nurses, roads is not there now. Indeed, some of those hospitals, schools and museums may not even have been built yet. But Dave feels that loss of money very personally. Money which he could spend here, and now on, any number of Bright Shiny Things. And it is no good telling him “Dave-most of these Bright Shiny Things, that you covet so desperately, will have no value in the long term. Remember how you longed for an Austin Healey, a record by the Bay City Rollers, Watneys Red Barrel, a bottle of Hirondelle, a quadrophonic stereo? All good in their day, no doubt-but are they quite what they were, have not other things come along to take their places?

But Dave knows things that we do not. Has studied authors that we have never heard of. Like Thorstein Veblen who as long ago as 1899 showed that people buy Bright Shiny Things not because those things are useful, but to signal the wealth, status and sophistication of the buyer. To consume conspicuously, ostentatiously, vainly, and emptily. To doom themselves thereby to domination by rich men, and to conquest by foreign ones. Oh well. We tried to warn.

Veblen, T: The Theory of the Leisure Class: An Economic Study in the Evolution of Institutions (1899).

#economics #taxes # finance #history #veblen #consumer society #production #marketing