Of all the columnists we follow, Camilla Cavendish of the Financial Times is one of the most clear-eyed and objective. But the reason we’re showcasing her today is because she has turned her mind to that old LSS favourite: conspiracy theories and their devotees. Here is the reference [1] but because it’s behind the FT paywall* we’ll provide a short summary, clearly distinguishing Camilla’s points from our own riff on them, which is demarcated below.
CAMILLA SAYS
She notes sadly that an old pal (University educated!) has fallen for the hoary old belief that anthropogenic global warming is a hoax. Which leads her to consider why people need Conspiracy Theories: their History (apparently they had previous spikes around the troubled years 1900 and 1950): that people have an inherent tendency to believe facts that confirm their existing beliefs: and most chilling of all, that believing one conspiracy acts as a gateway to believing all, as the susceptible mind links the dots between anything and everything. Astutely, she notes that the provision of facts and reason almost never help the sufferers, because these do not address the deep emotional and psychological needs which are really driving participation in these modern cults. She even provides further reading: a book called Foolproof: why we Fall for Misinformation by Professor Sander. Camilla concludes with an admirable determination to read more things that she disagrees with. A form of mental training also recommended by Bertrand Russell, another much admired favourite of this blog.
OUR THOUGHTS
She’s right, sadly. For us, what’s so depressing is the way that conspiracy theories and misinformation on just about anything choke up the worldwide interweb like bindweed in a garden. The intellectual level of much conspiracy discourse-the use of language, evidence and reason-reminds us of the old Anonymous Letters we used to examine long ago in a Police Laboratory, long before the internet could spread such rubbish universally. So we’ve little enough to add, frankly. Except perhaps some further reading into Social Identity Theory as pioneered by the great Drs Tajfel and Turner [3], and its depressing observations that the species we are forced to belong to tends to draw its conclusions about what is true from the opinions of others rather than an objective consideration of the facts. In which case the only remedy is to choose you friends, family and above all, masters, with extreme care.
* or is it? Gentle readers when we clicked on this the whole thing came up in which case you can read all of Camilla’s article for yourselves. Go on, try it
[1] It’s far too easy to get sucked down a conspiracy theory rabbit hole
[2] Foolproof: Why We Fall for Misinformation and How to Build Immunity
London: Fourth Estate, 2023.ISBN: 978-0008466764
Conspiracy theory #climate change #misinformation #internet #social identity theory #camilla cavendish #financial times
Learning, Science and Society 